Season 1
Abigail’s Picks
Best: “Broken Mirror”, “The Popular Kids”, and “Somebody’s Watching”
Worst: “Machismo”, “Derailed”, and “What Fresh Hell”
Mac’s Picks
Best: “Somebody’s Watching”, “The Fox”, “Compulsion”
Worst: “Machismo”, “Poison”, and “Blood Hungry”
Best: “Somebody’s Watching”
Worst: “Machismo”
Season 2
Abigail’s Picks
Best: “North Mammon”, “Sex, Birth and Death”, and “Open Season”
Worst: “Honor Among Thieves”, “No Way Out”, and “No Way Out Part 2”
Mac’s Picks
Best: “North Mammon”, “Jones”, and “Profiler, Profiled”
Worst: “P911”, “Psychodrama”, and “Ashes and Dust”
Best: “Profiler, Profiled”
Worst: “Honor Among Thieves”
Season 3
Abigail’s Picks
Best: “Penelope”, “Children of The Dark”, and “Damaged”
Worst: “7 Seconds”, “Scared to Death”, “Third Life”
Mac’s Picks
Best: “Lucky”, “Penelope”, and “About Face”
Worst: “7 Seconds”, “Scared to Death”, and “Limelight”
Best: “Penelope”
Worst: “Scared to Death”
Season 4
Abigail’s Picks
Best: “Masterpiece”, “Normal”, “Pleasure Is My Business”, “The Big Wheel”, “Amplification”
Worst: “House On Fire”, “Cold Comfort”, and “Catching Out”
Mac’s Picks
Best: “Pleasure Is My Business”, “Demonology”, “Masterpiece”, “The Big Wheel”, “Normal”, and “Zoe’s Reprise”
Worst: “Cold Comfort”, “Brothers In Arms”, and “House On Fire”
Best: “Normal”
Worst: “House On Fire”